Pizza Shop Erie, PA
View Our Menus! Downtown | Presque Isle
Call to ask about our daily specials!                
Downtown 814-454-2418 | Presque Isle 814-835-3400

Menu

Presque Isle Menu

Our Presque Isle Menu 


Pizza
Hand-Tossed, Stoned Baked
New York-Style Cheese: Medium 12” - $7.25 (Additional toppings $1.50) Large 16” - $10.25 (Additional toppings $2)

Pizza Toppings: Cheese ● Pepperoni ● Mushrooms ● Sausage ● Ham ● Meatballs ● Green Peppers ● Banana Peppers ● Jalapeño Peppers ● Black Olives ● Tomato ● Bacon ● Onion ● Broccoli ● Spinach ● Anchovies ● Pineapple
Specialty Pizza 

Cajun Chicken: Medium 12” - $11.99 Large 16” - $16.99
Chicken, honey mustard, mozzarella, ranch, Cajun seasoning 

Irish Pizza: Medium 12” - $11.99 Large 16” - $16.99
Artichokes, mushrooms, pesto, ricotta, mozzarella, white sauce 

Hawaiian Pizza: Medium 12” - $11.99 Large 16” - $16.99
Ham, bacon, pineapple, mozzarella, red sauce

Steak and Ranch: Medium 12” - $11.99 Large 16” - $16.99
Ranch, thinly sliced steak, red onion, cheese

Stevo’s Supreme: Medium 12” - $11.99 Large 16” - $16.99
Pepperoni, cheese, mushrooms, green peppers, onion, sausage

Chicken Ranch: Medium 12” - $11.99 Large 16” - $16.99
Ranch dressing, chicken, bacon, tomato, cheese 

Buffalo Chicken: Medium 12” - $11.99 Large 16” - $16.99
Hot Buffalo sauce, ranch, grilled chicken, peppers, onion, cheese

Buffalo Steak: Medium 12” - $11.99 Large 16” - $16.99
Hot Buffalo sauce, ranch, thinly sliced steak, peppers, onion, cheese

Philly Steak: Medium 12” - $11.99 Large 16” - $16.99
Pizza sauce, cheese, thinly sliced steak, peppers 

Meat Lover: Medium 12” - $11.99 Large 16” - $16.99
Pepperoni, ham, sausage, bacon, cheese
Nightmare: Medium 12” - $11.99 Large 16” - $16.99
Meatballs, pepperoni, peppers, onion, banana peppers, jalapeño peppers 

BBQ Chicken: Medium 12” - $11.99 Large 16” - $16.99
BBQ sauce, grilled chicken, peppers, onion, cheese

Veggie Supreme: Medium 12” - $10.99 Large 16” - $15.99
Green peppers, onion, black olives, tomato, mushrooms

White Pizza: Medium 12” - $10.99 Large 16” - $15.99
Tomato, onion, black olives, cheese, Romano cheese 

Tomato Broccoli: Medium 12” - $10.99 Large 16” - $15.99
Tomato, broccoli, garlic, Romano cheese, mozzarella 

Tomato Spinach: Medium 12” - $10.99 Large 16” - $15.99
Spinach, garlic, Romano cheese, mozzarella

Chicago White: Medium 12” - $10.99 Large 16” - $15.99
Black olives, onion, mushrooms, banana peppers, Romano and mozzarella cheeses 

Greek Pizza: Medium 12” - $10.99 Large 16” - $15.99
Mozzarella cheese, with feta, tomato, black olives, onion
14” Deep Dish Pizza

Menu

14” Stuffed Pizza

Stevo’s Best! 
14” for $19.99
Choice of Filling: Meat Stuffed, Veggie Stuffed, Stevo’s Supreme 
For Ricotta Add $1.50 
Calzone

Menu

Wings
Served with Our Signature Specialty Sauce
Mild ● Medium ● Hot ● Butter & Garlic ● Ranch ● Western BBQ ● Hickory Smoked BBQ ● Honey Mustard ● Cajun ● Garlic Parmesan ● Cranch 

Menu

Wedge Sandwiches 
Made from fresh dough, stuffed, folded & baked in oven 

Menu

Mr. Sub’s Oven Baked Subs

Menu

Pasta In A Bread Bowl 

Menu

Salads
(Medium = M / Large = L)

Menu

Dressing Choices Include

Ranch ● Italian ● Fat Free Italian ● Honey French ● Greek Vinaigrette
Sides
Small = S / Large = L

Menu

Catering

(24-hour notice please)

Sub Tray: Serves 12-15 people - $31
Variety of cold cuts, turkey, roast beef, ham subs
3 or more: $29 each 
Salads

Menu

We Have Something for Everyone! Check Out Our Menu!

Share by: